Tiffany Nicole Foster, 35: Last Seen Leaving Her Apartment In 2021
Tiffany Nicole Foster vanished after leaving her home. She was set to go grocery shopping but never returned.
If you asked Tiffany Nicole Foster's loved ones to describe her, they would say she was a responsible person. The mother of three was a devoted parent dedicated to her job and education.
Tiffany, 35, was enrolled at Georgia Military College, majoring in criminal justice. While focusing on her studies, she also worked at Hello Fresh as a security guard. Her dedication was admired, and things seemed to be in line—but Tiffany was at odds with her fiancé, Reginald Robertson. Yet, it would only be months before she graduated and looked forward to a new career in law enforcement.
Our Black Girls is an independent, reader-supported publication. If you believe in amplifying the stories of missing Black women and girls, please consider making a direct gift through PayPal or Buy Me a Coffee, or by subscribing here.
On March 1, 2021, Tiffany left her home at the Lakeside Apartments in Newnan, Georgia. Fox 5 News reported that Robertson told police he saw his fiancée leave their shared residence and said she was going to the grocery store. The trip was supposed to take only a few minutes, but Tiffany never returned. The next day, she didn’t show up to school, either. Still, Robertson did not report his fiancée missing.
Three days after she vanished, Tiffany also missed her shift at work, and it was her mother who called the police. Quickly, Robertson became a person of interest. The couple’s history fueled investigators, specifically a domestic violence incident that was said to have occurred in 2020.
“You can’t explain the feeling. I have sad days where I just cry all day,” Tiffany’s mother, Katrina Hill, told 11 Alive News.
One week after Tiffany Nicole Foster went missing, her vehicle was located. On March 8, her Nissan Altima was recovered almost 30 miles away in College Park. Tiffany’s purse, keys, and only bank card were inside the car. Nevertheless, police still had Robertson in their sights, and in April 2021, just one month after Tiffany mysteriously disappeared, he was arrested. However, it wasn’t about the disappearance.
“I don’t get any sleep—wondering where she is, what happened. It’s just devastating,” Tiffany’s mother said.
The domestic violence incident from November 2020 was still an open case, and Robertson was arrested and charged with kidnapping and aggravated assault. Meanwhile, as they looked into Tiffany’s missing-person case, police found that Robertson had moved her car to College Park. He was later charged with theft, but that charge was dropped.
“I don’t want to keep having these anniversaries. I wish that we could find her. Yeah, so we could just kind of put the pieces together,” Tiffany’s sister, Kim Bryan, told Fox 5 News in March 2023. Tiffany’s mother would add elsewhere, “I just want to know where my baby is. Is she OK? I just need answers and closure. And justice will l follow after that.”
Larry Starks, Tiffany’s father, passed away at 65. Kim believes the weight of Tiffany’s case greatly affected his health.
Then, in 2025, NBC News reported that Reginald Robertson was tried and found guilty of Tiffany’s murder. The outlet stated: “He faced multiple charges, including felony and malice murder, concealing a death, rape, kidnapping, and fraud. Although Tiffany’s body has not been found, authorities at the time said evidence confirmed she is deceased.”
Additionally, “he was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole for the kidnapping, rape and malice murder charges. He was sentenced to an additional 80 years in prison for the other seven counts, which included burglary, aggravated assault, concealing the death of another and fraud.”
Another man, Jeremy Walker Sr., was also tried in connection with this case. He was “convicted of theft by taking but acquitted of concealing the death of another. He was sentenced to 10 years in prison,” per NBC News.
Tiffany Foster: What To Know
At the time of her disappearance, Tiffany Nicole Foster stood 5 feet 2 and weighed 220 pounds. She has hazel eyes and short, black/dark brown hair, but Tiffany is known to wear wigs. She was last seen wearing a black body suit that zips up the back. Tiffany also has a heart-shaped tattoo on the back of her right shoulder reading “Big Sister 12-7-97.” Her red birthmark runs from her back down her left arm. Tiffany has used the last names “Starks” and “Hill.” Both ears are pierced.
Anyone with information about this case is urged to contact the Coweta County Sheriff’s Office at (678) 423-6711 or their local law enforcement agency. The agency case number is 2103000085. These investigators can also be reached here Inv. Kilgore at skilgore@coweta.ga.us or Inv. Stapler at cstapler@coweta.ga.us—both at (770) 253-1502.
A significant reward is reportedly being issued in this case. Please contact the authorities for details.
Please share this story about Tiffany Nicole Foster to help bring a resolution to her missing person and murder case. She is our sister, and her life matters.
Case Number: 2103000085
Agency: Coweta County Sheriff’s Office
Phone: (678) 423-6711
Join the Our Black Girls conversations on Facebook, Instagram, X, and TikTok, as well as on the OBG Podcasts on Apple, Spotify, Google, and Anchor FM. Stay updated on the latest cases, developments, messages from survivors, and much more.